May 11, 2005
No vaccines for us this year
When my dog gets her spring checkup Friday, she will not be getting any yearly vaccines. This year I will have the vet draw her blood to perform a titer. The sample will then be checked in a lab to see if she has adequate levels of antibodies in her system to protect her from disease. Odds are VERY high that Charlee won't need to be vaccinated again for some time - with the exception of having to get her rabies vaccine renewed every three years. Current research supports the evidence that most vaccines are effective for at least several years in protecting our pets. Annual renewal is both unnecessary and potentially injurious to their longterm health.
Many of you may already be aware that, due to the tireless efforts of Kris Christine of Alna , and others, Maine’s outdated rabies vaccination protocol has been changed. It used to be mandatory that Maine's dogs be innoculated every two years. That requirement has been amended now to every three years. Kris began her crusade for change to this requirement after her own dog Meadow developed tumors at the site of his rabies vaccine within days of being innoculated. Her experience is not unique. I have heard of countless vaccine-related problems ranging from tumors, cancer, seizures, behavioral problems, aggression, skin/coat and allergy conditions arising from excessive or premature innoculations. I hear these reports daily from clients, friends, colleagues and from the numerous professional dog training lists to which I belong.
My own beloved dog Dina died from a brain tumor. My Boston vet had recommended we vaccinate her for rabies every year instead of following Massachusett's required three-year protocol because of local concerns involving racoons and rabies. I followed his advice, trusting his professional judgment. However, in hindsight (and after much reading and research) I now believe that Dina's condition was brought on or accelerated by vaccinosis
- complications caused by vaccine toxicity. Each spring Dina experienced what we called 'reverse sneezes' so my vet, attributing her sneezing to seasonal changes, recommended she be given powerful steroids and allergy medications. As I reflect back, I now realize that Dina never 'reverse- sneezed' or had seizures prior to that time. It is also likely that she received the one-year vaccine instead of the three-year vaccine in error and was poisoned by an overconcentration of toxins.
What you can do:
- Be an informed and responsible pet owner and do the research yourself! (I have yet to forgive myself for blindly following the vet's advice and allowing Dina to be vaccinated every year for rabies).
- Ask your vet about having a titer performed for your dog(s). If you decide to titer your dog, don’t be persuaded by the “it’s cheaper” speech advocating you go ahead and multiply vaccinate your dog anyway. With more and more dogs developing post-vaccination complications it won't be cheaper for you or better for the dog in the long run if they develop a life-threatening complication.
- Keep accurate records of the dates that your dog has been vaccinated. Many people are telling me that they are still getting bi-yearly and even yearly reminders from their vet for rabies shots due.
- Consider backing this bill, Ld 429 advocating full disclosure. What started in Maine by Kris has spread nationwide. Realize that all medicines and vaccines (whether they're intended for human or animal use) can have inherent risks and potential side effects. I believe it is our personal responsibility to act as well-informed consumers and research the pros and cons of each drug we're contemplating. It is unlikely that the current standards of vaccinations will change without more supporting data, but I do know that 27 major vet schools are now recommending these revised vaccine protocols.
- If you really want to get the ball rolling you can join this new Class Action Lawsuit that is aimed at changing the current vaccine protocol.
- If your dog is over six years of age or has a medical condition that could be compromised by vaccinations, please consider having him titered instead of administering a yearly vaccine.
- It's important to remember though that your dog should still be seen for his yearly veterinary examination whether you elect to skip an annual vaccination or not. Many problems are picked up with early detection during the yearly examination. Many vets are concerned that that their clients might skip yearly examinations if the current protocols should change. I share their concern about this and can't stress enough how important it is to make an appointment to have your dog seen by a vet at least once a year.
- Share this vaccine information with friends, family and other animal lovers.
Looking for more info? Try these links:
Lots of great info here at the canine epilepsy site. You will need to search a bit.
For a super slide presention by Dr. Bob Rogers DVM
Try New vaccination protocols
The Vaccine Question by Dr. Richard Pitcairn
Surf Doglogic's web site and Shirley's Wellness Cafe
Hi Nancy,
I have a rescue that I adopted almost 2 years ago. She was having petite siezures during backward sneezing the first few months we had her. She had been given all her vaccinations and spayed - huge stress on the immune system. She hasn't had any more vaccinations since then and we have used homopathics to detox her, and only occassionaly backward sneezes in reaction to wheat products. But nothing like when we got her, she actually fell over on the floor during each episode.
Anyway, appreciate your article and have seen the ravages of over vaccination in my own dogs. boo hoo, lost one to cancer.
Posted by
chrisMay 10, 2005 04:02 PM
My cat was diagnosed with kidney failure over a year ago. At that time the vet (at North Deering Veterinary Hospital) told me there are some who believe that distemper shots (possibly among others) put too much of a stress on the kidneys. There's nothing conclusive that I know of, but since Max only has a third of his kidney function, I think this time we're going to skip it and be nice to his kidneys.
Posted by
WendyMay 10, 2005 05:12 PM
thany you, Nancy, for such a timely report. Your column is excellent, informative, enlightening, and funny. Perhaps if enough people begin requesting annual titers, local vets will begin to acknowledge "vaccinosis" and other problems caused by "preventative" treatments. Keep up the good work.
Posted by
WendyMay 10, 2005 08:53 PM
Excellent info Nancy!
I hope some vets read it. I helped update VT's rabies law the same way last year, so this year annual licences only require rabies within three years instead of two. As a former ACO (animal control officer, aka "dog catcher"), I must concur that annual vet exams are still necessary as are annual registrations or licencing, to make you check your records and give a little monetary help to the local ACO's and spay/neuter programs. Use that vet visit to insist your vet do the titers or find a lab that does, I had to go to 8 vets in VT before finding one who would send the titers to a lab (for more than the price of the six-way vacc!) Also, there's only one who uses homeopathics on dogs in northern VT, and he's so busy he won't take any new clients. So despite the number of vets around, getting them to help our dogs naturally is the current challenge. Happy hounds, Thia
Posted by
Thia ArtemisMay 10, 2005 09:18 PM
Cheers for the hardwork in Maine - you are leading the way in educating the public about pet over-vaccination.
If the public just starts asking pointed questions of their veterinarians in person (and not of the mostly brain-washed to sell staff - and they are brain-washed by the pharmaceutical companies and the vet that pushes them to help the business run a good profit, it is not their fault). Let the vet educate their staff, just make sure to ask a LOT of questions before you vaccinate. Education before Vaccination is a simple step to perserve your pets' health.
Go Maine!
Julie in California
Posted by
Julie Borst ReedMay 11, 2005 10:43 AM
Would like to know if there are any kennels that are accepting titers instead of vaccines in Southern Maine? I have decided not to do vaccines on our two Dobermans, except for 3 yr rabies, but when they do have to be kennelled, I end up having to do shots so I can get them in. Having in home care is not feasible for these two, they are happier in a kennel than staying home alone.
Any ideas on how to get around this annoying problem?
Hollis Center, ME
Posted by
PhyllisMay 11, 2005 12:25 PM
Hi Phyllis,
I called a few kennels that I have worked with in the past and they both told me they accept titers, but still require kennel cough. They both chose not to be named but suggested that you call around. :)))
-Nancy
Posted by
Nancy Freedman-SmithMay 11, 2005 12:38 PM
Please sign this petition. Type in Proheart in the search box if it comes up.
http://www.petitiononline.com/mod_perl/signed.cgi?ProHeart
I believe that many of us have had our pets over vaccinated because
we listened to our vets erroneous suggestions. I know I did and had
two healthy dogs die in the past 10 months for no other obvious reasons. I
have been told that one of my dogs went into CHF because of the
overload of vaccinesthat were given each and every year as is standard but is wrong
protocol.
If your pets has been over vaccinated please email the law firm and tell them.
petvaccine@childresslaw.net
Please go to the following websites that have a lot of information backing this claim up and please help save some doggie & kitty lives.
www.critterfixer.com
www.dogsadversereactions.com
www.groups.yahoo.com/group/vetandpetunhealthcaremalpractice/
www.groups.yahoo.com/group/doghealth2/
www.rimadyldeath.com
Posted by
mikeMay 11, 2005 01:51 PM
Great job Nancy, thank you for standing up for all the pets out there.
Posted by
JuneMay 12, 2005 06:51 AM
Nancy~Thank you so much for the informative and timely article. On April 15, 2005 after exhaustive efforts to diagnois my 5 year old corgi's condition AND visits to 4 vets (including 1 diagnostic "specialist" in Portland who shall remain nameless) we were told that Sadie had less than 2 weeks to live. All of them agreed that she had terminal liver disease and all categorically denied that innoculations had anything to do with her condition. I am absolutely POSITIVE that Proheart was the cause. So without their support we began our research and developed a holistic treatment plan including daily doses of vitamins and various herbs including milk thistle...proven to heal a damaged liver. Can you believe that none of the vets even mentioned this well known fact? I am happy to report that Sadie is doing amazingly well! It's titer tests for us in the future...and far less trust in the veterinary world.
Posted by
FrancineMay 14, 2005 07:32 AM
Hi Francine,
What an amazing story. Pro-heart 6 is a (voluntary?) recalled heartworm product that was given by injection and touted as lasting 6 months.
Can you share with us what holistic treatment you followed and where you found out about it?
So happy to here that your Corgi is doing well.
-Nancy
Posted by
Nancy Freedman-SmithMay 14, 2005 04:04 PM
Hi Nancy~
Thanks for your note. Sadie received her last proheart injection in '04 just a couple of months before this drug was recalled. When I heard that it had been taken off the market I immediately contacted my vet...seems they hadn't heard about it yet...hmmm?
Our holistic approach to "healing" her damaged liver is quite detailed and includes 1.) a modified raw diet (fresh vegetables and no red meat) w/ Wysong dog supplements, garlic, soy & flax seed oil 2.) 100 mg of Milk Thistle/day (to repair and rejuvenate liver) 3.) Vitamin E supplements (anti oxidants and aids circulation) and SAM-e (stimulates liver regeneration) 4. Ursodiol 100 mg/day aids in removing toxins from the system (must be prescribed by your vet)
5. Plenty of LOVE and SUNSHINE!
There are a number of good resources out there both online and in hard copy....we've taken away valuable information from all of them. For me, I found Cyndi Smasal's book HOPE FOR HEALING LIVER DISEASE IN YOUR DOG an excellent resource; Dr. Pitcairn's book should be on every "care givers" reading list...
Before our "treatments" Sadie had lost 1/4 of her body weight (she had been unable to hold down food for nearly 20 days). Today she has regained all but 1 pound, LOVES her food, is bright eyed & free of jaundice and her energy levels increases every day. We are thankful for each day...she is such a joy!
Posted by
FrancineMay 15, 2005 08:18 AM
Good article. Fortunately, my vet in Cape Elizabeth noted on my annual reminder postcard that my dog was vaccinated 2 years ago and is not scheduled for re-innoculation until next year. But I will ask about testing for the antibodies for the other vaccines.
Right now, a major concern of mine is that my dog tests positive for Lyme every year, even though he has no signs of the illness and I treated him with antibiotics when he was first diagnosed three years ago. I think the tests they use indicate prior exposure, not current infection. I don't think animals should be given heavy doses of antibiotics every year as a precaution any more than people should be abusing them. Most people consider their pets to be members of the family and treat them as they do their children. The practice of treating them like barnyard guinea pigs will be a thing of the past if we stay educated and stand our ground.
Posted by
ShaneMay 17, 2005 09:51 AM
Let's not forget the cats!
Visit:
www.vas-awareness.org
and
www.catshots.com
to learn about the deadly side effect of vaccines in cats -
vaccine/injection related sarcomas.
Posted by
LynnMay 17, 2005 10:06 AM
All medicaitons have inherant risks. Even the vitamins we all stuff down our throats have horrible risks. You take Johns Wort with a particular antidepressant and it can kill you. You take too much vitamin E and your on coumadin - well-all I can say is -don't stick yourself.
I have a number of points.
1. If nbc reported- it is is true? well maybe. After 4 heavy years of watching politics I turned my tv off with the exception of c-span -because for two years i watched my local and national not tell the turth. I have seen people hurt personally because of untrue news stories. Not on NBC but on another station I actually witnessed the news being bought and paid for.
Yes some dogs have terrible reactions to vaccinations but I would put forward another theory about poor breeding practices that affect in immune system of a dog that makes it easier to get immunological disorders. Just a thought.
Thats why I support, as a person that rescues Golden Retrivers, my friends that support responsible breeding and also canine cancer research.
This is not something that happens with just animals-it happens with humans also. Looks at diseases like MS.
I don't know any veternarians in Maine but I know hundreds of them in Florida. It is a huge topic of discussion.
I can assure you that most agonize over vaccinations. Untill a few years there was no real researach going on because basically there was no money to pay for it.
Most veternarians I know are well versed in this issue -because they have to be.
If people are really concerned then find a researacher -raise some money -do some studies and get them published. Not only does it give you credibility but in the end does an incredible humane service.
I'm sure that most people reading Nancy's Blog have never seen a dog die from distemper. I have. It quite horrible. Two summers ago we have 8 golden s in a row die ahorrible death from distemper.
Nancy you should not feel guilty about what happened to your beloved dog Dina. Brain tumors in dogs are caused by a variety of things.
Cyndi Lenz RN
www.goldenrescuesouthflorida.com
Posted by
Cyndi LenzMay 17, 2005 11:19 AM
One critical point that has been left out, and MUST be understood: the "3-yr. vaccine" and the "1-yr vaccine" are the same identical pharmaceutical product--NO difference in the vial contents AT ALL. The re-labelling is a loop hole for shelters and vets to continue sending out those recall cards for yearly boosters.
Posted by
sethMay 18, 2005 03:38 PM
Why do we have to give Rabies shot every three years?They should except a titers test in it's place. It's like taken your car that is full of gas and trying to pump more in. I must remind everyone about titers testing. There is no such thing as " Oh! your dog is low on the titers test so he needs another shot WRONG!!! This means that the dog is not fighting any kind of infection and if it is high, this means he is fighting a disease. But if it shows up at all the animal is fully covered. If you did a titers on a new born puppy it would show it was fully protected through the Mothers milk!!! Keep talking to others and let us get the MERCURY POISON OUT OF OUR VACCINES AND WE COULD STOP CANCER!
Posted by
AdrienneJune 14, 2005 02:58 PM
After reading everyone comments you all need to go to the book store and pick up THE NATURE OF ANIMAL HEALING BY MARTIN GOLDSTEIN, DVM. if you truely love your animals. A Vet that really speaks out and tells the thruth to pet owners. It's the answers you need to know. Tell Others.
Posted by
AdrienneJune 14, 2005 03:12 PM
Post a comment